Scoop Election 08: edited by Gordon Campbell

Gordon Campbell on the Police being above the law

October 18th, 2013

A lot of the time, policing is a difficult and unpleasant job and when its done well, the Police get little credit for doing it. However, no-one benefits – including the Police who are trying to do the job properly – when bad policing is insulated from effective punishment. The examples of bad policing are piling up, where Police break the law with impunity, do harm to ordinary citizens and get away with it, scot free.

For example: a police officer in Christchurch in an unmarked car stopped Russell Byfield, could offer no identification when asked for it, followed Byfield home, beat him up so severely that Byfield is still incapacitated and then had him convicted for assault. ACC chimed in and initially refused Byfield compensation, by ruling that his condition was degenerative, rather than caused by the police beating. Two years later, the courts threw out the assault conviction and Byfield has also just won a five year battle for backdated ACC compensation. But the police officer concerned, Ron Greatorex?

Greatorex has never been charged and still works as a senior-ranking police officer in Christchurch. At the time of the assault, Greatorex was a senior member of the police staff safety tactical training team in Christchurch. Police said Greatorex was investigated in 2011, but that “none of the complaints made by Mr Byfield were upheld”, despite a High Court ruling quashing the man’s convictions. Byfield told the Sunday Star-Times the assault had been “horrific” and he was still taking pain medication for a permanent neck injury and he was “in a lot of pain and not sleeping well at all”.

Or what about this case, cited on RNZ this morning in the context of calls to broaden the powers of the Independent Police Conduct Authority. In essence, a preventable police chase that should have been terminated resulted in the chased car hitting a teenager and killing him. No blame was attached to officers who maintained the chase after it had begun to pose a danger to the public, and where there sufficient staff on duty to apprehend the offender by other means. No change either – apparently – to the Police “hot pursuit” policy, which keeps on killing people even though other countries have shown that alternatives to such car chases are available, and are effective. Thirdly, there was the case of the party in Khandallah, where the Police illegally entered a property in Khandallah to close down a party and used excessive force, such that teenager Jakob Christie had his neck broken by a police baton. The Police then failed to investigate the subsequent complaints properly, and leaked aspects of the investigation to the media to discredit its critics. From the IPCA Authority findings:

The Authority received ten complaints from partygoers about the actions of Police the nature of which ranged from Police forcing entry to the house, to allegations that Tactical Policing Unit officers used batons to strike people at the party and forcibly removed them from the house by pushing, shoving and manhandling them. The Authority also received two subsidiary complaints about the leaking of a preliminary Police report to the media and alleged dishonesty in accounts recorded in documents by specific officers. Independent Police Conduct Authority Chair Judge Sir David Carruthers said today although the Tactical Policing Unit was responding to a call from a partygoer concerned about the behaviour of gatecrashers, the decision to close the party down was contrary to law.

“The force used to remove partygoers from the house in an effort to shut down the party was also excessive and contrary to law. The action of a Tactical Policing Unit officer in striking one of the partygoers with a baton, using excessive force, was also contrary to law. Medical records show that this young man sustained a displaced fracture of the C7 spinous process, or a broken neck, as a result of the officer’s action,” Sir David said.

In addition to the main investigation, the Authority conducted a subsidiary investigation which examined the unauthorised disclosure of the Police preliminary report which was sent by an office administrator at Police National Headquarters to a media outlet. The Authority is satisfied that no one else was involved in posting the report to media and that the disclosure of the report was carried out in an effort to discredit a complainant.

As the RNZ report indicates, the IPCA cannot – under its present powers – mount prosecutions against Police officers who have acted illegally. Despite the word “ independent” in its title, the IPCA also employs former Police officers among its staff. Given the high emphasis on collegial loyalty among Police officers – not for nothing has that collegiality been likened to a gang culture – this does not inspire any confidence that the IPCA will act in an impartial fashion when investigating its own. Clearly, there is a need for a body that is not only nominally independent, but is seen to be independent. To re-inforce such a perception – and to underline the independence of the Police officers on its staff – the IPCA’s findings need to be given real teeth, via the power to initiate legal proceedings. Currently, the IPCA looks more like a smokescreen designed to absorb and divert criticism, since it can only make recommendations that continue to fall on deaf ears. There is no mood in government to do things any differently.

Little chance either, of the Police mending their ways. In the wake of the critical IPCA findings on the Jakob Christie case, the Police reaction has been all too typical:

Responding to a damning Independent Police Conduct Authority report, Assistant Commissioner Gran Nicholls said while police had misinterpreted the law they had acted in “good faith”. He also refused to confirm whether police would apologise to Jakob Christie, whose neck was broken while police broke up the Khandallah party in September 2009. “The issue of an apology is something that we are going to explore with Mr Christie,” he said. “It is something we need to do in a private context.” Despite breaking the law by entering the house, Nicholls said none of the 11 officers involved had been, or would be, disciplined.

Nothing to see here, move on. Or else.

Obama Wins a Smashing Victory

On paper, the deal to resolve the US debt ceiling crisis is only a temporary one, but the Republicans have been so bloodied by this beating – the polls had them being held responsible for this crisis by a three to one margin – they will be very unlikely to try this on again. If they do, they will be virtually gifting the 2014 mid-term elections to the Democrats. Paradoxically, while the Republican Party has taken a hammering, the main Tea Party leader – notably, Ted Cruz, the junior Senator from Texas – seems to have emerged from the ruins as a populist hero, for making one last stand at the Alamo against the socialist evils of Obamacare. As one Republican analyst bitterly put it, Ted Cruz has driven the Republican Party through the carwash, but he’s the only one who didn’t get wet.

So far, the most interesting aspect of the final “ deal” is that so little dealing was done. This time, Obama didn’t budge. None of the aspects of Obamacare that the Republicans had targeted were given away to achieve a solution. The Republicans folded. Which, as John Dickerson pointed out on Slate, underlines an interesting aspect of the Obama presidency. Despite all the energy and public goodwill Obama has spent on futile searches for compromise, his positive legacy will consist of those occasions when he pursued his own agenda : on the stimulus package, on Obamacare, and during this 2013 debt crisis. Bi-partisanship simply hasn’t worked ; and the quest for it was never the basis of his mandate. Way back in 2008 when there were such hopes for this presidency, Obama was given a strong mandate for change. The presidency is deceptive in that respect. Ostensibly, the office is meant to be bispartisan in that Mr President governs for all Americans. In reality though, those Presidents seen as great ( eg Lincoln, Roosevelt, Kennedy on civil rights and yes, Reagan) have been those who made their partisan agenda into the new norm for the nation. Obama was elected to lead in that mould, and his only victories have arisen from the very few times that he has acted on that mandate. Even then, on two of those occasions – the stimulus package and this recent crisis – his actions were in response to events that were forced upon him. Faint hope, but maybe he should try to lead from the front, in the short time that’s now left to him.


Share and Enjoy: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Scoopit
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • NewsVine
  • Print this post Print this post
    1. 12 Responses to “Gordon Campbell on the Police being above the law”

    2. By Big Mike on Oct 18, 2013 | Reply

      Cry and whinge all you like about how much you hate the police, safe and secure in the knowledge that when you need them they won’t take it personally. What a luxury!
      Or simply abide by the law and common courtesy and you’ll never have a negative experience with police.

    3. By Robert on Oct 18, 2013 | Reply

      I’ve never been convicted of a crime in my life. In 25 years of having a license I have never caused an accident and had just one speeding ticket when someone was following to close. Just like you say innocent people are the ones harassed by police who question everyone you know about crimes they are investigating without telling the victims/suspects?

    4. By Robert on Oct 18, 2013 | Reply

      NZ police are all stupid

    5. By Nick Gibbs on Oct 19, 2013 | Reply

      An excellent and informative article on the police. Without a truely independent complaints authority – one with real teeth- the police will continue to lose public trust.

    6. By Malcolm on Oct 19, 2013 | Reply

      You might like to read “Cover-Ups & Cop Outs” by Tom Lewis. Find out why Ann Hercus left; I mean the real reason.

    7. By Joe Blow on Oct 19, 2013 | Reply

      As the decision of Justice Gittos to allow a private prosecution of Banks shows, the only way to get justice in New Zealand these days is to mount your own prosecution. Maybe we should provide legal aid to anyone who has strong grounds for a private prosecution?

      Putting the independence of the IPCA to one side, the other thing that doesn’t help with police conduct is s 30 of the Evidence Act. The courts are interpreting it way too loosely allowing improperly obtained evidence to be admitted despite police misconduct. As far as the courts are concerned the police are almost always acting in “good faith” which is why it has become the police’s motif when faced with challenges to police misconduct.

    8. By Fats on Nov 2, 2013 | Reply

      The long list of cases over recent decades (Arthur Allan Thomas, Lunday, Bain etc) suggests that there’s something rotten in our police system – right at the top. They turn a blind eye to attempts to pervert the course of justice and then praise offending officers as ‘men of the highest integrity’. In Britain, they’re finally cleaning out their police force and it might be time to consider a purge of our upper ranks. We might even have to bring in new blood from overseas to supervise the process.

    9. By simon rolleston on Nov 7, 2013 | Reply

      If the Police make a mistake,and they all do at some stage,then a standard social attitude is that you apologise.If the police are guilty of a series of mistakes-say the David Bain ‘investigation’-then a more intense form of societal sanction is required. To have the Police disavow they had anything to do with such obvious ‘ cock-ups’ is an insult to law abiding citizens.

    10. By Russell Byfield on Nov 24, 2013 | Reply

      I am the Russell Byfield who was Badly assaulted leaving myself permanently injured by Ron Greatorex. I have numerous written information that in my mind clearly makes it obvious that this Ron Greatorex not only assaulted me on my own private property, but he further committed Perjury to have me convicted of wrongful convictions. Eye witness’s too are available who are as myself disgraced in a Policeman investigating a Policeman. All of NZ etc need to Know this Man and our system is very Damaging to our People and it’s time it Stopped.

    11. By onenzer on Nov 28, 2013 | Reply

      russell byfield, i feel that at last nzers are awakening to our hugely corrupt police force. a good start would be for all doctors, who have been called to repair people beaten by police in cells, to stand up shout and and be counted.

    12. By onenzer on Nov 28, 2013 | Reply

      russell byfield, i feel that at last nzers are awakening to our hugely corrupt police force. a good start would be for all doctors, who have been called to repair people beaten by police in cells, to stand up shout and be counted.

    13. By Russell Byfield on Dec 4, 2013 | Reply

      Hi Onezer,
      That would be a darn good start, as I am sure the New Zealand doctors have witnessed horrific bodily and physiologic damages by the police. unfortunately I believe some have been threatened by police as how they believe these damages by Police personal have occurred. It needs to stop, we need a truly independent system that can charge and bring someone who has assaulted another person to the court even a policeman, they (police) should not be immune as they currently are. The evidence against this Ron Greatorex and the system around him is obvious to say the least. The man clearly lost control and assaulted me badly and broke many many laws in doing so, then this system went on to protect him or themselves

    Post a Comment